Copyright © 2002 W3C® (MIT, INRIA, Keio), All Rights Reserved. W3C liability, trademark, document use, and software licensing rules apply.
This document specifies usage scenarios for the W3C XML Query data model, algebra, and query language.
The material in this document was previously contained in the W3C XML Requirements. Due to its length, we have placed it in a separate document. This is a W3C Working Draft for review by W3C Members and other interested parties. It is a draft document and may be updated, replaced or made obsolete by other documents at any time. It is inappropriate to use W3C Working Drafts as reference material or to cite them as other than "work in progress". This is work in progress and does not imply endorsement by the W3C membership.
This document has been produced as part of the W3C XML Activity, following the procedures set out for the W3C Process. The document has been written by the XML Query Working Group ( W3C members only). The goals of the XML Query working group are discussed in the XML Query Working Group charter ( W3C members only).
The XML Query Working Group feels that the contents of this Working Draft are relatively stable, and therefore encourages feedback on this version.
Patent disclosures relevant to this specification may be
found on the XML Query Working Group's patent
disclosure page, which can be found at
http://www.w3.org/2002/08/xmlquery-IPR-statements
.
Comments on this document should be sent to the W3C mailing list public-qt-comments@w3.org@w3.org (archived at http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-qt-comments/).
A list of current W3C Recommendations and other technical documents can be found at http://www.w3.org/TR/.
1 Use Cases for XML Queries
1.1 Use Case "XMP": Experiences and Exemplars
1.1.1 Document Type Definitions (DTD)
1.1.2 Sample Data
1.1.3 DTD for Q5
1.1.4 Sample Data for Q5
1.1.5 DTD for Q9
1.1.6 Data for Q9
1.1.7 DTD for Q10
1.1.8 Data for Q10
1.1.9 Queries and Results
1.1.9.1 Q1
1.1.9.2 Q2
1.1.9.3 Q3
1.1.9.4 Q4
1.1.9.5 Q5
1.1.9.6 Q6
1.1.9.7 Q7
1.1.9.8 Q8
1.1.9.9 Q9
1.1.9.10 Q10
1.1.9.11 Q11
1.1.9.12 Q12
1.2 Use Case "TREE": Queries that preserve hierarchy
1.2.1 Description
1.2.2 Document Type Definition (DTD)
1.2.3 Sample Data
1.2.4 Queries and Results
1.2.4.1 Q1
1.2.4.2 Q2
1.2.4.3 Q3
1.2.4.4 Q4
1.2.4.5 Q5
1.2.4.6 Q6
1.3 Use Case "SEQ" - Queries based on Sequence
1.3.1 Description
1.3.2 Document Type Definition (DTD)
1.3.3 Sample Data
1.3.4 Queries and Results
1.3.4.1 Q1
1.3.4.2 Q2
1.3.4.3 Q3
1.3.4.4 Q4
1.3.4.5 Q5
1.4 Use Case "R" - Access to Relational Data
1.4.1 Description
1.4.2 Document Type Definition (DTD)
1.4.3 Sample Data
1.4.4 Queries and Results
1.4.4.1 Q1
1.4.4.2 Q2
1.4.4.3 Q3
1.4.4.4 Q4
1.4.4.5 Q5
1.4.4.6 Q6
1.4.4.7 Q7
1.4.4.8 Q8
1.4.4.9 Q9
1.4.4.10 Q10
1.4.4.11 Q11
1.4.4.12 Q12
1.4.4.13 Q13
1.4.4.14 Q14
1.4.4.15 Q15
1.4.4.16 Q16
1.4.4.17 Q17
1.4.4.18 Q18
1.5 Use Case "SGML": Standard Generalized Markup Language
1.5.1 Description
1.5.2 Document Type Definition (DTD)
1.5.3 Sample Data
1.5.4 Queries and Results
1.5.4.1 Q1
1.5.4.2 Q2
1.5.4.3 Q3
1.5.4.4 Q4
1.5.4.5 Q5
1.5.4.6 Q6
1.5.4.7 Q7
1.5.4.8 Q8a
1.5.4.9 Q8b
1.5.4.10 Q9
1.5.4.11 Q10
1.6 Use Case "TEXT": Full-text Search
1.6.1 Description
1.6.2 Document Type Definition (DTD)
1.6.3 Sample Data
1.6.4 Queries and Results
1.6.4.1 Q1
1.6.4.2 Q2
1.6.4.3 Q4
1.6.4.4 Q5
1.7 Use Case "NS" - Queries Using Namespaces
1.7.1 Description
1.7.2 Document Type Definition (DTD)
1.7.3 Sample Data
1.7.4 Queries and Results
1.7.4.1 Q1
1.7.4.2 Q2
1.7.4.3 Q3
1.7.4.4 Q4
1.7.4.5 Q5
1.7.4.6 Q6
1.7.4.7 Q7
1.7.4.8 Q8
1.8 Use Case "PARTS" - Recursive Parts Explosion
1.8.1 Description
1.8.2 Document Type Definitions (DTD)
1.8.3 Sample Data
1.8.4 Queries and Results
1.8.4.1 Q1
1.9 Use Case "STRONG" - queries that exploit strongly typed data
1.9.1 Description
1.9.2 Schema
1.9.3 Sample Data
1.9.4 Queries and Results
1.9.4.1 Q1
1.9.4.2 Q2
1.9.4.3 Q3
1.9.4.4 Q4
1.9.4.5 Q5
1.9.4.6 Q6
1.9.4.7 Q7
1.9.4.8 Q8
1.9.4.9 Q9
1.9.4.10 Q10
1.9.4.11 Q11
A Acknowledgements
B References (Non-Normative)
The use cases listed below were created by the XML Query Working Group to illustrate important applications for an XML query language. Each use case is focused on a specific application area, and contains a Document Type Definition (DTD) and example input data. Each use case specifies a set of queries that might be applied to the input data, and the expected results for each query. Since the English description of each query is concise, the expected results form an important part of the definition of each query, specifying the expected output format. These use cases were originally published as part of the W3C XML Query Requirements document, without solutions in concrete query languages. Now it is being republished with solutions for XQuery.
Several implementors have asked that we make the queries from these use cases available in a separate file to make it easier for them to test their parsers. These queries may be found in [Use Case Sample Queries]. Also, the queries from the XQuery specification itself have been made available in [XQuery Sample Queries].
Some of the use cases assume that input is provided in
the form of one or more documents with specific names such
as "http://www.bn.com/bib.xml". Other use cases are based
on implicit (unnamed) input documents, which are accessed using
the input()
function. The input environment
for each use case is stated in its Document Type Definition
(DTD) section.
To make output more readable, the output of queries has been formatted using whitespace which may not be returned by a query processor. This whitespace should not be considered normative for the correctness of results.
These use cases represent a snapshot of an ongoing work. Some important application areas are not yet adequately covered by a use case. The XML Query Working Group reserves the right to add, delete, or modify individual queries or whole use cases as the work progresses. The presence of a query in this set of use cases does not necessarily indicate that the query will be expressible in the XML Query Language(s) to be created by the XML Query Working Group.
This use case contains several example queries that illustrate requirements gathered from the database and document communities.
Most of the example queries in this use case are based on a bibliography document named "http://www.bn.com/bib.xml" with the following DTD:
<!ELEMENT bib (book* )> <!ELEMENT book (title, (author+ | editor+ ), publisher, price )> <!ATTLIST book year CDATA #REQUIRED > <!ELEMENT author (last, first )> <!ELEMENT editor (last, first, affiliation )> <!ELEMENT title (#PCDATA )> <!ELEMENT last (#PCDATA )> <!ELEMENT first (#PCDATA )> <!ELEMENT affiliation (#PCDATA )> <!ELEMENT publisher (#PCDATA )> <!ELEMENT price (#PCDATA )>
Here is the data found at www.bn.com/bib.xml:
<bib> <book year="1994"> <title>TCP/IP Illustrated</title> <author><last>Stevens</last><first>W.</first></author> <publisher>Addison-Wesley</publisher> <price> 65.95</price> </book> <book year="1992"> <title>Advanced Programming in the Unix environment</title> <author><last>Stevens</last><first>W.</first></author> <publisher>Addison-Wesley</publisher> <price>65.95</price> </book> <book year="2000"> <title>Data on the Web</title> <author><last>Abiteboul</last><first>Serge</first></author> <author><last>Buneman</last><first>Peter</first></author> <author><last>Suciu</last><first>Dan</first></author> <publisher>Morgan Kaufmann Publishers</publisher> <price>39.95</price> </book> <book year="1999"> <title>The Economics of Technology and Content for Digital TV</title> <editor> <last>Gerbarg</last><first>Darcy</first> <affiliation>CITI</affiliation> </editor> <publisher>Kluwer Academic Publishers</publisher> <price>129.95</price> </book> </bib>
Q5 also uses information on book reviews and prices from a separate data source named "http://www.amazon.com/reviews.xml" with the following DTD:
<!ELEMENT reviews (entry*)> <!ELEMENT entry (title, price, review)> <!ELEMENT title (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT price (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT review (#PCDATA)>
Here are the contents of "http://www.amazon.com/reviews.xml":
<reviews> <entry> <title>Data on the Web</title> <price>34.95</price> <review> A very good discussion of semi-structured database systems and XML. </review> </entry> <entry> <title>Advanced Programming in the Unix environment</title> <price>65.95</price> <review> A clear and detailed discussion of UNIX programming. </review> </entry> <entry> <title>TCP/IP Illustrated</title> <price>65.95</price> <review> One of the best books on TCP/IP. </review> </entry> </reviews>
Q9 uses an input document named "books.xml", with the following DTD:
<!ELEMENT chapter (title, section*)> <!ELEMENT section (title, section*)> <!ELEMENT title (#PCDATA)>
Here are the contents of books.xml:
<chapter> <title>Data Model</title> <section> <title>Syntax For Data Model</title> </section> <section> <title>XML</title> <section> <title>Basic Syntax</title> </section> <section> <title>XML and Semistructured Data</title> </section> </section> </chapter>
Q10 uses an input document named "prices.xml", with the following DTD:
<!ELEMENT prices (book*)> <!ELEMENT book (title, source, price)> <!ELEMENT title (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT source (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT price (#PCDATA)>
Here are the contents of prices.xml:
<prices> <book> <title>Advanced Programming in the Unix environment</title> <source>www.amazon.com</source> <price>65.95</price> </book> <book> <title>Advanced Programming in the Unix environment </title> <source>www.bn.com</source> <price>65.95</price> </book> <book> <title>TCP/IP Illustrated</title> <source>www.amazon.com</source> <price>65.95</price> </book> <book> <title>TCP/IP Illustrated</title> <source>www.bn.com</source> <price>65.95</price> </book> <book> <title>Data on the Web</title> <source>www.amazon.com</source> <price>34.95</price> </book> <book> <title>Data on the Web</title> <source>www.bn.com</source> <price>39.95</price> </book> </prices>
List books published by Addison-Wesley after 1991, including their year and title.
Solution in XQuery:
<bib> { for $b in document("http://www.bn.com")/bib/book where $b/publisher = "Addison-Wesley" and $b/@year > 1991 return <book year="{ $b/@year }"> { $b/title } </book> } </bib>
Expected Result:
<bib> <book year="1994"> <title>TCP/IP Illustrated</title> </book> <book year="1992"> <title>Advanced Programming in the Unix environment</title> </book> </bib>
Create a flat list of all the title-author pairs, with each pair enclosed in a "result" element.
Solution in XQuery:
<results> { for $b in document("http://www.bn.com")/bib/book, $t in $b/title, $a in $b/author return <result> { $t } { $a } </result> } </results>
Expected Result:
<results> <result> <title>TCP/IP Illustrated</title> <author> <last>Stevens</last> <first>W.</first> </author> </result> <result> <title>Advanced Programming in the Unix environment</title> <author> <last>Stevens</last> <first>W.</first> </author> </result> <result> <title>Data on the Web</title> <author> <last>Abiteboul</last> <first>Serge</first> </author> </result> <result> <title>Data on the Web</title> <author> <last>Buneman</last> <first>Peter</first> </author> </result> <result> <title>Data on the Web</title> <author> <last>Suciu</last> <first>Dan</first> </author> </result> </results>
For each book in the bibliography, list the title and authors, grouped inside a "result" element.
Solution in XQuery:
<results> { for $b in document("http://www.bn.com")/bib/book return <result> { $b/title } { $b/author } </result> } </results>
Expected Result:
<results> <result> <title>TCP/IP Illustrated</title> <author> <last>Stevens</last> <first>W.</first> </author> </result> <result> <title>Advanced Programming in the Unix environment</title> <author> <last>Stevens</last> <first>W.</first> </author> </result> <result> <title>Data on the Web</title> <author> <last>Abiteboul</last> <first>Serge</first> </author> <author> <last>Buneman</last> <first>Peter</first> </author> <author> <last>Suciu</last> <first>Dan</first> </author> </result> <result> <title>The Economics of Technology and Content for Digital TV</title> </result> </results>
For each author in the bibliography, list the author's name and the titles of all books by that author, grouped inside a "result" element.
Solution in XQuery:
<results> { for $a in distinct-values(document("http://www.bn.com")//author) return <result> { $a } { for $b in document("http://www.bn.com")/bib/book where some $ba in $b/author satisfies deep-equal($ba,$a) return $b/title } </result> } </results>
In the above query, deep-equal() tests to see if the two nodes have the same structure and values.
Expected Result:
<results> <result> <author> <last>Stevens</last> <first>W.</first> </author> <title>TCP/IP Illustrated</title> <title>Advanced Programming in the Unix environment</title> </result> <result> <author> <last>Abiteboul</last> <first>Serge</first> </author> <title>Data on the Web</title> </result> <result> <author> <last>Buneman</last> <first>Peter</first> </author> <title>Data on the Web</title> </result> <result> <author> <last>Suciu</last> <first>Dan</first> </author> <title>Data on the Web</title> </result> </results>
For each book found at both bn.com and amazon.com, list the title of the book and its price from each source.
Solution in XQuery:
<books-with-prices> { for $b in document("www.bn.com/bib.xml")//book, $a in document("www.amazon.com/reviews.xml")//entry where $b/title = $a/title return <book-with-prices> { $b/title } <price-amazon>{ $a/price/text() }</price-amazon> <price-bn>{ $b/price/text() }</price-bn> </book-with-prices> } </books-with-prices>
Expected Result:
<books-with-prices> <book-with-prices> <title>TCP/IP Illustrated</title> <price-amazon>65.95</price-amazon> <price-bn> 65.95</price-bn> </book-with-prices> <book-with-prices> <title>Advanced Programming in the Unix environment</title> <price-amazon>65.95</price-amazon> <price-bn>65.95</price-bn> </book-with-prices> <book-with-prices> <title>Data on the Web</title> <price-amazon>34.95</price-amazon> <price-bn>39.95</price-bn> </book-with-prices> </books-with-prices>
For each book that has at least one author, list the title and first two authors, and an empty "et-al" element if the book has additional authors.
Solution in XQuery:
<bib> { for $b in document("www.bn.com/bib.xml")//book where count($b/author) > 0 return <book> { $b/title } { for $a in $b/author[position()<=2] return $a } { if (count($b/author) > 2) then <et-al/> else () } </book> } </bib>
Expected Result:
<bib> <book> <title>TCP/IP Illustrated</title> <author> <last>Stevens</last> <first>W.</first> </author> </book> <book> <title>Advanced Programming in the Unix environment</title> <author> <last>Stevens</last> <first>W.</first> </author> </book> <book> <title>Data on the Web</title> <author> <last>Abiteboul</last> <first>Serge</first> </author> <author> <last>Buneman</last> <first>Peter</first> </author> <et-al/> </book> </bib>
List the titles and years of all books published by Addison-Wesley after 1991, in alphabetic order.
Solution in XQuery:
<bib> { for $b in document("www.bn.com/bib.xml")//book where $b/publisher = "Addison-Wesley" and $b/@year > 1991 return <book> { $b/@year } { $b/title } </book> sort by (title) } </bib>
Expected Result:
<bib> <book year="1992"> <title>Advanced Programming in the Unix environment</title> </book> <book year="1994"> <title>TCP/IP Illustrated</title> </book> </bib>
Find books in which the name of some element ends with the string "or" and the same element contains the string "Suciu" somewhere in its content. For each such book, return the title and the qualifying element.
Solution in XQuery:
for $b in document("www.bn.com/bib.xml")//book let $e := $b/*[contains(string(.), "Suciu") and ends-with(local-name(.), "or")] where exists($e) return <book> { $b/title } { $e } </book>
In the above solution, string(), local-name() and ends-with() are functions defined in the Functions and Operators document.
Expected Result:
<book> <title>Data on the Web</title> <author> <last>Suciu</last> <first>Dan</first> </author> </book>
In the document "books.xml", find all section or chapter titles that contain the word "XML", regardless of the level of nesting.
Solution in XQuery:
<results> { for $t in document("books.xml")//(chapter | section)/title where contains($t/text(), "XML") return $t } </results>
Expected Result:
<results> <title>XML</title> <title>XML and Semistructured Data</title> </results>
In the document "prices.xml", find the minimum price for each book, in the form of a "minprice" element with the book title as its title attribute.
Solution in XQuery:
<results> { let $doc := document("www.bn.com/bib.xml") for $t in distinct-values($doc//book/title) let $p := for $x in $doc//book[title = $t]/price return decimal($x) return <minprice title="{ $t/text() }"> <price>{ min($p) }</price> </minprice> } </results>
Expected Result:
<results> <minprice title="Advanced Programming in the Unix environment"> <price>65.95</price> </minprice> <minprice title="TCP/IP Illustrated"> <price>65.95</price> </minprice> <minprice title="Data on the Web"> <price>34.95</price> </minprice> </results>
For each book with an author, return the book with its title and authors. For each book with an editor, return a reference with the book title and the editor's affiliation.
Solution in XQuery:
<bib> { for $b in document("www.bn.com/bib.xml")//book[author] return <book> { $b/title } { $b/author } </book> } { for $b in document("www.bn.com/bib.xml")//book[editor] return <reference> { $b/title } {$b/editor/affiliation} </reference> } </bib>
Expected Result:
<bib> <book> <title>TCP/IP Illustrated</title> <author> <last>Stevens</last> <first>W.</first> </author> </book> <book> <title>Advanced Programming in the Unix environment</title> <author> <last>Stevens</last> <first>W.</first> </author> </book> <book> <title>Data on the Web</title> <author> <last>Abiteboul</last> <first>Serge</first> </author> <author> <last>Buneman</last> <first>Peter</first> </author> <author> <last>Suciu</last> <first>Dan</first> </author> </book> <reference> <title>The Economics of Technology and Content for Digital TV</title> <affiliation>CITI</affiliation> </reference> </bib>
Find pairs of books that have different titles but the same set of authors (possibly in a different order).
Solution in XQuery:
<bib> { for $book1 in document("www.bn.com/bib.xml")//book, $book2 in document("www.bn.com/bib.xml")//book let $aut1 := $book1/author sort by (last, first), $aut2 := $book2/author sort by (last, first) where $book1 << $book2 and not($book1/title = $book2/title) and sequence-deep-equal($aut1, $aut2) return <book-pair> { $book1/title } { $book2/title } </book-pair> } </bib>
Expected Result:
<bib> <book-pair> <title>TCP/IP Illustrated</title> <title>Advanced Programming in the Unix environment</title> </book-pair> </bib>
The above solution uses a function, sequence-deep-equal(), which compares sequences. Two sequences are equal if all items in corresponding positions in the two sequences are equal - if the sequences are node sequences, the values of the nodes are used for comparison.
Some XML document-types have a very flexible structure in which text is mixed with elements and many elements are optional. These document-types show a wide variation in structure from one document to another. In documents of these types, the ways in which elements are ordered and nested are usually quite important.
An XML query language should have the ability to extract elements from documents while preserving their original hierarchy. This Use Case illustrates this requirement by means of a flexible document type named Book.
This use case is based on an input document named "book.xml", with the following DTD:
<!DOCTYPE book [ <!ELEMENT book (title, author+, section+)> <!ELEMENT title (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT author (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT section (title, (p | figure | section)* )> <!ATTLIST section id ID #IMPLIED difficulty CDATA #IMPLIED> <!ELEMENT p (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT figure (title, image)> <!ATTLIST figure width CDATA #REQUIRED height CDATA #REQUIRED > <!ELEMENT image EMPTY> <!ATTLIST image source CDATA #REQUIRED > ]>
The queries in this use case are based on the following sample data.
<?xml version="1.0"?> <!DOCTYPE book SYSTEM "book.dtd"> <book> <title>Data on the Web</title> <author>Serge Abiteboul</author> <author>Peter Buneman</author> <author>Dan Suciu</author> <section id="intro" difficulty="easy" > <title>Introduction</title> <p>Text ... </p> <section> <title>Audience</title> <p>Text ... </p> </section> <section> <title>Web Data and the Two Cultures</title> <p>Text ... </p> <figure height="400" width="400"> <title>Traditional client/server architecture</title> <image source="csarch.gif"/> </figure> <p>Text ... </p> </section> </section> <section id="syntax" difficulty="medium" > <title>A Syntax For Data</title> <p>Text ... </p> <figure height="200" width="500"> <title>Graph representations of structures</title> <image source="graphs.gif"/> </figure> <p>Text ... </p> <section> <title>Base Types</title> <p>Text ... </p> </section> <section> <title>Representing Relational Databases</title> <p>Text ... </p> <figure height="250" width="400"> <title>Examples of Relations</title> <image source="relations.gif"/> </figure> </section> <section> <title>Representing Object Databases</title> <p>Text ... </p> </section> </section> </book>
Prepare a (nested) table of contents for Book1, listing all the sections and their titles. Preserve the original attributes of each <section> element, if any.
Solution in XQuery:
define function toc( element $e ) returns element* { let $n := local-name( $e ) return if ($n = "section") then <section> { $e/@* } { toc($e/*) } </section> else if ($n = "title") then $e else () } <toc> { toc( document("book1.xml")/book ) } </toc>
Expected Result:
<toc> <section id="intro" difficulty="easy"> <title>Introduction</title> <section> <title>Audience</title> </section> <section> <title>Web Data and the Two Cultures</title> </section> </section> <section id="syntax" difficulty="medium"> <title>A Syntax For Data</title> <section> <title>Base Types</title> </section> <section> <title>Representing Relational Databases</title> </section> <section> <title>Representing Object Databases</title> </section> </section> </toc>
Prepare a (flat) figure list for Book1, listing all the figures and their titles. Preserve the original attributes of each <figure> element, if any.
Solution in XQuery:
<figlist> { for $f in document("book1.xml")//figure return <figure> { $f/@* } { $f/title } </figure> } </figlist>
Expected Result:
<figlist> <figure height="400" width="400"> <title>Traditional client/server architecture</title> </figure> <figure height="200" width="500"> <title>Graph representations of structures</title> </figure> <figure height="250" width ="400"> <title>Examples of Relations</title> </figure> </figlist>
How many sections are in Book1, and how many figures?
Solution in XQuery:
<section_count>{ count(document("book1.xml")//section) }</section_count>, <figure_count>{ count(document("book1.xml")//figure) }</figure_count>
Expected Result:
<section_count>7</section_count> <figure_count>3</figure_count>
How many top-level sections are in Book1?
Solution in XQuery:
<top_section_count> { count(document("book1.xml")/book/section) } </top_section_count>
Expected Result:
<top_section_count>2</top_section_count>
Make a flat list of the section elements in Book1. In place of its original attributes, each section element should have two attributes, containing the title of the section and the number of figures immediately contained in the section.
Solution in XQuery:
<section_list> { for $s in document("book1.xml")//section let $f := $s/figure return <section title="{ $s/title/text() }" figcount="{ count($f) }"/> } </section_list>
Expected Result:
<section_list> <section title="Introduction" figcount="0"/> <section title="Audience" figcount="0"/> <section title="Web Data and the Two Cultures" figcount="1"/> <section title="A Syntax For Data" figcount="1"/> <section title="Base Types" figcount="0"/> <section title="Representing Relational Databases" figcount="1"/> <section title="Representing Object Databases" figcount="0"/> </section_list>
Make a nested list of the section elements in Book1, preserving their original attributes and hierarchy. Inside each section element, include the title of the section and an element that includes the number of figures immediately contained in the section.
Solution in XQuery:
define function section_summary(element $s) returns element { <section> { $s/@* } { $s/title } <figcount>{ count($s/figure) }</figcount> { for $ss in $s/section return section_summary($ss) } </section> } <toc> { for $s in document("book.xml")/book/section return section_summary($s) } </toc>
Expected Result:
<toc> <section id="intro" difficulty="easy"> <title>Introduction</title> <figcount>0</figcount> <section> <title>Audience</title> <figcount>0</figcount> </section> <section> <title>Web Data and the Two Cultures</title> <figcount>1</figcount> </section> </section> <section id="syntax" difficulty="medium"> <title>A Syntax For Data</title> <figcount>1</figcount> <section> <title>Base Types</title> <figcount>0</figcount> </section> <section> <title>Representing Relational Databases</title> <figcount>1</figcount> </section> <section> <title>Representing Object Databases</title> <figcount>0</figcount> </section> </section> </toc>
This use case illustrates queries based on the sequence in which elements appear in a document.
Although sequence is not significant in most traditional database systems or object systems, it can be quite significant in structured documents. This use case presents a series of queries based on a medical report.
This use case is based on a medical report using the HL7 Patient Record Architecture. We simplify the DTD in this example, using only what is needed to understand the queries.
<!DOCTYPE report [ <!ELEMENT report (section*)> <!ELEMENT section (section.title, section.content)> <!ELEMENT section.title (#PCDATA )> <!ELEMENT section.content (#PCDATA | anesthesia | prep | incision | action | observation )*> <!ELEMENT anesthesia (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT prep ( (#PCDATA | action)* )> <!ELEMENT incision ( (#PCDATA | geography | instrument)* )> <!ELEMENT action ( (#PCDATA | instrument )* )> <!ELEMENT observation (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT geography (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT instrument (#PCDATA)> ]>
The queries in this use case are based on the following sample data.
<report> <section> <section.title>Procedure</section.title> <section.content> The patient was taken to the operating room where she was placed in supine position and <anesthesia>induced under general anesthesia.</anesthesia> <prep> <action>A Foley catheter was placed to decompress the bladder</action> and the abdomen was then prepped and draped in sterile fashion. </prep> <incision> A curvilinear incision was made <geography>in the midline immediately infraumbilical</geography> and the subcutaneous tissue was divided <instrument>using electrocautery.</instrument> </incision> The fascia was identified and <action>#2 0 Maxon stay sutures were placed on each side of the midline. </action> <incision> The fascia was divided using <instrument>electrocautery</instrument> and the peritoneum was entered. </incision> <observation>The small bowel was identified.</observation> and <action> the <instrument>Hasson trocar</instrument> was placed under direct visualization. </action> <action> The <instrument>trocar</instrument> was secured to the fascia using the stay sutures. </action> </section.content> </section> </report>
In the Procedure section of Report1, what Instruments were used in the second Incision?
Solution in XQuery:
for $s in document("report1.xml")//section[section.title = "Procedure"] return ($s//incision)[2]/instrument
Expected Result:
<instrument>electrocautery</instrument>
In the Procedure section of Report1, what are the first two Instruments to be used?
Solution in XQuery:
for $s in document("report1.xml")//section[section.title = "Procedure"] return ($s//instrument)[position()<=2]
Expected Result:
<instrument>using electrocautery.</instrument> <instrument>electrocautery</instrument>
In Report1, what Instruments were used in the first two Actions after the second Incision?
Solution in XQuery:
let $i2 := (document("report1.xml")//incision)[2] for $a in (document("report1.xml")//action)[. >> $i2][position()<=2] return $a//instrument
Expected Result:
<instrument>Hasson trocar</instrument> <instrument>trocar</instrument>
In Report1, find "Procedure" sections where no Anesthesia element occurs before the first Incision
Solution in XQuery:
for $p in document("report1.xml")//section[section.title = "Procedure"] where not(some $a in $p//anesthesia satisfies $a << ($p//incision)[1] ) return $p
Expected Result:
(No sections satisfy Q4, thankfully.)
In Report1, what happened between the first Incision and the second Incision?
Solution in XQuery:
define function precedes(node $a, node $b) returns boolean { $a << $b and empty($a//node() intersect $b) } define function follows(node $a, node $b) returns boolean { $a >> $b and empty($b//node() intersect $a) } <critical_sequence> { let $proc := document("report1.xml")//section[section.title="Procedure"][1] for $n in $proc//node() where follows($n, ($proc//incision)[1]) and precedes($n, ($proc//incision)[2]) return $n } </critical_sequence>
Here is another solution that is perhaps more efficient and less readable:
<critical_sequence> { let $proc := document("report1.xml")//section[section.title="Procedure"][1], $i1 := ($proc//incision)[1], $i2 := ($proc//incision)[2] for $n in $proc//node() except $i1//node() where $n >> $i1 and $n << $i2 return $n } </critical_sequence>
Expected Result:
<critical_sequence> The fascia was identified and <action>#2 0 Maxon stay sutures were placed on each side of the midline.</action>#2 0 Maxon stay sutures were placed on each side of the midline. </critical_sequence>
One important use of an XML query language will be to access data stored in relational databases. This use case describes one possible way in which this access might be accomplished.
A relational database system might present a view in which each table (relation) takes the form of an XML document. One way to represent a database table as an XML document is to allow the document element to represent the table itself, and each row (tuple) inside the table to be represented by a nested element. Inside the tuple-elements, each column is in turn represented by a nested element. Columns that allow null values are represented by optional elements, and a missing element denotes a null value.
As an example, consider a relational database used by an online auction. The auction maintains a USERS table containing information on registered users, each identified by a unique userid, who can either offer items for sale or bid on items. An ITEMS table lists items currently or recently for sale, with the userid of the user who offered each item. A BIDS table contains all bids on record, keyed by the userid of the bidder and the item number of the item to which the bid applies.
The three tables used by the online auction are below, with their column-names indicated in parentheses.
USERS ( USERID, NAME, RATING ) ITEMS ( ITEMNO, DESCRIPTION, OFFERED_BY, START_DATE, END_DATE, RESERVE_PRICE ) BIDS ( USERID, ITEMNO, BID, BID_DATE )
This use case is based on three separate input documents named users.xml, items.xml, and bids.xml. Each of the documents represents one of the tables in the relational database described above, using the following DTDs:
<!DOCTYPE users [ <!ELEMENT users (user_tuple*)> <!ELEMENT user_tuple (userid, name, rating?)> <!ELEMENT userid (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT name (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT rating (#PCDATA)> ]> <!DOCTYPE items [ <!ELEMENT items (item_tuple*)> <!ELEMENT item_tuple (itemno, description, offered_by, start_date?, end_date?, reserve_price? )> <!ELEMENT itemno (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT description (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT offered_by (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT start_date (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT end_date (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT reserve_price (#PCDATA)> ]> <!DOCTYPE bids [ <!ELEMENT bids (bid_tuple*)> <!ELEMENT bid_tuple (userid, itemno, bid, bid_date)> <!ELEMENT userid (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT itemno (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT bid (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT bid_date (#PCDATA)> ]>
Here is an abbreviated set of data showing the XML format of the instances:
<items> <item_tuple> <itemno>1001</itemno> <description>Red Bicycle</description> <offered_by>U01</offered_by> <start_date>1999-01-05</start_date> <end_date>1999-01-20</end_date> <reserve_price>40</reserve_price> </item_tuple> <!-- !!! Snip !!! --> <users> <user_tuple> <userid>U01</userid> <name>Tom Jones</name> <rating>B</rating> </user_tuple> <!-- !!! Snip !!! --> <bids> <bid_tuple> <userid>U02</userid> <itemno>1001</itemno> <bid>35</bid> <bid_date>1999-01-07</bid_date> </bid_tuple> <bid_tuple> <!-- !!! Snip !!! -->
The entire data set is represented by the following table:
USERID | NAME | RATING |
U01 | Tom Jones | B |
U02 | Mary Doe | A |
U03 | Dee Linquent | D |
U04 | Roger Smith | C |
U05 | Jack Sprat | B |
U06 | Rip Van Winkle | B |
ITEMNO | DESCRIPTION | OFFERED_BY | START_DATE | END_DATE | RESERVE_PRICE |
1001 | Red Bicycle | U01 | 1999-01-05 | 1999-01-20 | 40 |
1002 | Motorcycle | U02 | 1999-02-11 | 1999-03-15 | 500 |
1003 | Old Bicycle | U02 | 1999-01-10 | 1999-02-20 | 25 |
1004 | Tricycle | U01 | 1999-02-25 | 1999-03-08 | 15 |
1005 | Tennis Racket | U03 | 1999-03-19 | 1999-04-30 | 20 |
1006 | Helicopter | U03 | 1999-05-05 | 1999-05-25 | 50000 |
1007 | Racing Bicycle | U04 | 1999-01-20 | 1999-02-20 | 200 |
1008 | Broken Bicycle | U01 | 1999-02-05 | 1999-03-06 | 25 |
USERID | ITEMNO | BID | BID_DATE |
U02 | 1001 | 35 | 1999-01-07 |
U04 | 1001 | 40 | 1999-01-08 |
U02 | 1001 | 45 | 1999-01-11 |
U04 | 1001 | 50 | 1999-01-13 |
U02 | 1001 | 55 | 1999-01-15 |
U01 | 1002 | 400 | 1999-02-14 |
U02 | 1002 | 600 | 1999-02-16 |
U03 | 1002 | 800 | 1999-02-17 |
U04 | 1002 | 1000 | 1999-02-25 |
U02 | 1002 | 1200 | 1999-03-02 |
U04 | 1003 | 15 | 1999-01-22 |
U05 | 1003 | 20 | 1999-02-03 |
U01 | 1004 | 40 | 1999-03-05 |
U03 | 1007 | 175 | 1999-01-25 |
U05 | 1007 | 200 | 1999-02-08 |
U04 | 1007 | 225 | 1999-02-12 |
The following results assume that the queries were executed on Feb. 1, 1999.
List the item number and description of all bicycles that currently have an auction in progress, ordered by item number.
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { for $i in document("items.xml")//item_tuple where $i/start_date <= current-date() and $i/end_date >= current-date() and contains($i/description, "Bicycle") return <item_tuple> { $i/itemno } { $i/description } </item_tuple> sort by (itemno) } </result>
Expected Result:
<result> <item_tuple> <itemno>1003</itemno> <description>Old Bicycle</description> </item_tuple> <item_tuple> <itemno>1007</itemno> <description>Racing Bicycle</description> </item_tuple> </result>
For all bicycles, list the item number, description, and highest bid (if any), ordered by item number.
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { for $i in document("items.xml")//item_tuple let $b := document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple[itemno = $i/itemno] where contains($i/description, "Bicycle") return <item_tuple> { $i/itemno } { $i/description } <high_bid>{ max(for $z in $b/bid return decimal($z)) }</high_bid> </item_tuple> sort by (itemno) } </result>
Expected Result:
<result> <item_tuple> <itemno>1001</itemno> <description>Red Bicycle</description> <high_bid>55.0</high_bid> </item_tuple><item_tuple> <itemno>1003</itemno> <description>Old Bicycle</description> <high_bid>20.0</high_bid> </item_tuple><item_tuple> <itemno>1007</itemno> <description>Racing Bicycle</description> <high_bid>225.0</high_bid> </item_tuple><item_tuple> <itemno>1008</itemno> <description>Broken Bicycle</description> <high_bid></high_bid> </item_tuple> </result>
Find cases where a user with a rating worse (alphabetically, greater) than "C" is offering an item with a reserve price of more than 1000.
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { for $u in document("users.xml")//user_tuple for $i in document("items.xml")//item_tuple where $u/rating > "C" and $i/reserve_price > 1000 and $i/offered_by = $u/userid return <warning> { $u/name } { $u/rating } { $i/description } { $i/reserve_price } </warning> } </result>
Expected Result:
<result> <warning> <name>Dee Linquent</name> <rating>D</rating> <description>Helicopter</description> <reserve_price>50000</reserve_price> </warning> </result>
List item numbers and descriptions of items that have no bids.
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { for $i in document("items.xml")//item_tuple where empty(document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple[itemno = $i/itemno]) return <no_bid_item> { $i/itemno } { $i/description } </no_bid_item> } </result>
Expected Result:
<result> <no_bid_item> <itemno>1005</itemno> <description>Tennis Racket</description> </no_bid_item> <no_bid_item> <itemno>1006</itemno> <description>Helicopter</description> </no_bid_item> <no_bid_item> <itemno>1008</itemno> <description>Broken Bicycle</description> </no_bid_item> </result>
For bicycle(s) offered by Tom Jones that have received a bid, list the item number, description, highest bid, and name of the highest bidder, ordered by item number.
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { for $seller in document("users.xml")//user_tuple, $buyer in document("users.xml")//user_tuple, $item in document("items.xml")//item_tuple, $highbid in document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple where $seller/name = "Tom Jones" and $seller/userid = $item/offered_by and contains($item/description , "Bicycle") and $item/itemno = $highbid/itemno and $highbid/userid = $buyer/userid and $highbid/bid = max( for $x in document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple [itemno = $item/itemno]/bid return decimal($x) ) return <jones_bike> { $item/itemno } { $item/description } <high_bid>{ $highbid/bid }</high_bid> <high_bidder>{ $buyer/name }</high_bidder> </jones_bike> sort by (itemno) } </result>
The following alternate solution uses the
unordered
function to inform the query
processor that the order of the lists in the for clause is
not significant, which means that the tuples can be
generated in any order. This can enable better
optimization.
Alternate Solution in XQuery:
<result> { for $seller in unordered document("users.xml")//user_tuple, $buyer in unordered document("users.xml")//user_tuple, $item in unordered document("items.xml")//item_tuple, $highbid in document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple where $seller/name = "Tom Jones" and $seller/userid = $item/offered_by and contains($item/description , "Bicycle") and $item/itemno = $highbid/itemno and $highbid/userid = $buyer/userid and $highbid/bid = max(for $x in unordered document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple [itemno = $item/itemno]/bid return decimal(data($x))) return <jones_bike> { $item/itemno } { $item/description } <high_bid>{ $highbid/bid }</high_bid> <high_bidder>{ $buyer/name }</high_bidder> </jones_bike> sort by (itemno) } </result>
Expected Result:
<result> <jones_bike> <itemno>1001</itemno> <description>Red Bicycle</description> <high_bid> <bid>55</bid> </high_bid> <high_bidder> <name>Mary Doe</name> </high_bidder> </jones_bike> </result>
For each item whose highest bid is more than twice its reserve price, list the item number, description, reserve price, and highest bid.
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { for $item in document("items.xml")//item_tuple let $b := document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple[itemno = $item/itemno] let $z := max(for $x in $b/bid return decimal($x)) where $item/reserve_price * 2 < $z return <successful_item> { $item/itemno } { $item/description } { $item/reserve_price } <high_bid>{$z }</high_bid> </successful_item> } </result>
Expected Result:
<result> <successful_item> <itemno>1002</itemno> <description>Motorcycle</description> <reserve_price>500</reserve_price> <high_bid>1200.0</high_bid> </successful_item> <successful_item> <itemno>1004</itemno> <description>Tricycle</description> <reserve_price>15</reserve_price> <high_bid>40.0</high_bid> </successful_item> </result>
Find the highest bid ever made for a bicycle or tricycle.
Solution in XQuery:
let $allbikes := document("items.xml")//item_tuple [contains(description, "Bicycle") or contains(description, "Tricycle")] let $bikebids := document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple[itemno = $allbikes/itemno] return <high_bid> { max(for $x in $bikebids/bid return decimal($x)) } </high_bid>
Expected Result:
<high_bid>225.0</high_bid>
How many items were actioned (auction ended) in March 1999?
Solution in XQuery:
let $item := document("items.xml")//item_tuple [end_date >= date("1999-03-01") and end_date <= date("1999-03-31")] return <item_count> { count($item) } </item_count>
Expected Result:
<item_count>3</item_count>
List the number of items auctioned each month in 1999 for which data is available, ordered by month.
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { let $end_dates := document("items.xml")//item_tuple/end_date for $m in distinct-values(for $e in $end_dates return get-month-from-date($e)) let $item := document("items.xml") //item_tuple[get-year-from-date(end_date) = 1999 and get-month-from-date(end_date) = $m] return <monthly_result> <month>{ $m }</month> <item_count>{ count($item) }</item_count> </monthly_result> sort by (month) } </result>
Expected Result:
<result> <monthly_result> <month>01</month> <item_count>1</item_count> </monthly_result> <monthly_result> <month>02</month> <item_count>2</item_count> </monthly_result> <monthly_result> <month>03</month> <item_count>3</item_count> </monthly_result> <monthly_result> <month>04</month> <item_count>1</item_count> </monthly_result> <monthly_result> <month>05</month> <item_count>1</item_count> </monthly_result> </result>
For each item that has received a bid, list the item number, the highest bid, and the name of the highest bidder, ordered by item number.
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { for $highbid in document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple, $user in document("users.xml")//user_tuple where $user/userid = $highbid/userid and $highbid/bid = max(for $x in document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple [itemno=$highbid/itemno]/bid return decimal($x)) return <high_bid> { $highbid/itemno } { $highbid/bid } <bidder>{ $user/name/text() }</bidder> </high_bid> sort by (itemno) } </result>
Expected Result:
<result> <high_bid> <itemno>1001</itemno> <bid>55</bid> <bidder>Mary Doe</bidder> </high_bid> <high_bid> <itemno>1002</itemno> <bid>1200</bid> <bidder>Mary Doe</bidder> </high_bid> <high_bid> <itemno>1003</itemno> <bid>20</bid> <bidder>Jack Sprat</bidder> </high_bid> <high_bid> <itemno>1004</itemno> <bid>40</bid> <bidder>Tom Jones</bidder> </high_bid> <high_bid> <itemno>1007</itemno> <bid>225</bid> <bidder>Roger Smith</bidder> </high_bid> </result>
List the item number and description of the item(s) that received the highest bid ever recorded, and the amount of that bid.
Solution in XQuery:
let $highbid := max(for $x in document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple/bid return decimal($x)) return <result> { for $item in document("items.xml")//item_tuple, $b in document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple[itemno = $item/itemno] where $b/bid = $highbid return <expensive_item> { $item/itemno } { $item/description } <high_bid>{ $highbid }</high_bid> </expensive_item> } </result>
Expected Result:
<result> <expensive_item> <itemno>1002</itemno> <description>Motorcycle</description> <high_bid>1200.0</high_bid> </expensive_item> </result>
List the item number and description of the item(s) that received the largest number of bids, and the number of bids it (or they) received.
Solution in XQuery:
define function bid_summary () { for $i in distinct-values(document("bids.xml")//itemno) let $b := document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple[itemno = $i] return <bid_count> { $i } <nbids>{ count($b) }</nbids> </bid_count> } <result> { let $bid_counts := bid_summary(), $maxbids := max(for $x in $bid_counts/nbids return decimal($x)), $maxitemnos := $bid_counts[nbids = $maxbids] for $item in document("items.xml")//item_tuple, $bc in $bid_counts where $bc/nbids = $maxbids and $item/itemno = $bc/itemno return <popular_item> { $item/itemno } { $item/description } <bid_count>{ $bc/nbids/text() }</bid_count> </popular_item> } </result>
Expected Result:
<result> <popular_item> <itemno>1001</itemno> <description>Red Bicycle</description> <bid_count>5</bid_count> </popular_item> <popular_item> <itemno>1002</itemno> <description>Motorcycle</description> <bid_count>5</bid_count> </popular_item> </result>
For each user who has placed a bid, give the userid, name, number of bids, and average bid, in order by userid.
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { for $uid in distinct-values(document("bids.xml")//userid), $u in document("users.xml")//user_tuple[userid = $uid] let $b := document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple[userid = $uid] return <bidder> { $u/userid } { $u/name } <bidcount>{ count($b) }</bidcount> <avgbid>{ avg(for $x in $b/bid return decimal($x)) }</avgbid> </bidder> sort by (userid) } </result>
Expected Result:
<result> <bidder> <userid>U01</userid> <name>Tom Jones</name> <bidcount>2</bidcount> <avgbid>220.0</avgbid> </bidder> <bidder> <userid>U02</userid> <name>Mary Doe</name> <bidcount>5</bidcount> <avgbid>387.0</avgbid> </bidder> <bidder> <userid>U03</userid> <name>Dee Linquent</name> <bidcount>2</bidcount> <avgbid>487.5</avgbid> </bidder> <bidder> <userid>U04</userid> <name>Roger Smith</name> <bidcount>5</bidcount> <avgbid>266.0</avgbid> </bidder> <bidder> <userid>U05</userid> <name>Jack Sprat</name> <bidcount>2</bidcount> <avgbid>110.0</avgbid> </bidder> </result>
List item numbers and average bids for items that have received three or more bids, in descending order by average bid.
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { for $i in distinct-values(document("bids.xml")//itemno) let $b := document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple[itemno = $i] where count($b) >= 3 return <popular_item> { $i } <avgbid>{ avg(for $x in $b/bid return decimal($x)) }</avgbid> </popular_item> sort by (decimal(avgbid) descending) } </result>
Expected Result:
<result> <popular_item> <itemno>1002</itemno> <avgbid>800.0</avgbid> </popular_item> <popular_item> <itemno>1007</itemno> <avgbid>200.0</avgbid> </popular_item> <popular_item> <itemno>1001</itemno> <avgbid>45.0</avgbid> </popular_item> </result>
List names of users who have placed multiple bids of at least $100 each.
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { for $u in document("users.xml")//user_tuple let $b := document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple[userid=$u/userid and bid>=100] where count($b) > 1 return <big_spender>{ $u/name/text() }</big_spender> } </result>
Expected Result:
<result> <big_spender>Mary Doe</big_spender> <big_spender>Dee Linquent</big_spender> <big_spender>Roger Smith</big_spender> </result>
List all registered users in order by userid; for each user, include the userid, name, and an indication of whether the user is active (has at least one bid on record) or inactive (has no bid on record).
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { for $u in document("users.xml")//user_tuple let $b := document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple[userid = $u/userid] return <user> { $u/userid } { $u/name } { if (empty($b)) then <status>inactive</status> else <status>active</status> } </user> sort by (userid) } </result>
Expected Result:
<result> <user> <userid>U01</userid> <name>Tom Jones</name> <status>active</status> </user> <user> <userid>U02</userid> <name>Mary Doe</name> <status>active</status> </user> <user> <userid>U03</userid> <name>Dee Linquent</name> <status>active</status> </user> <user> <userid>U04</userid> <name>Roger Smith</name> <status>active</status> </user> <user> <userid>U05</userid> <name>Jack Sprat</name> <status>active</status> </user> <user> <userid>U06</userid> <name>Rip Van Winkle</name> <status>inactive</status> </user> </result>
List the names of users, if any, who have bid on every item.
Solution in XQuery:
<frequent_bidder> { for $u in document("users.xml")//user_tuple where every $item in document("items.xml")//item_tuple satisfies some $b in document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple satisfies ($item/itemno = $b/itemno and $u/userid = $b/userid) return $u/name } </frequent_bidder>
Expected Result:
<frequent_bidder />
(No users satisfy Q17.)
List all users in alphabetic order by name. For each user, include descriptions of all the items (if any) that were bid on by that user, in alphabetic order.
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { for $u in document("users.xml")//user_tuple return <user> { $u/name } { for $b in distinct-values(document("bids.xml")//bid_tuple [userid = $u/userid]/itemno), $i in document("items.xml")//item_tuple[itemno = $b] return <bid_on_item>{ $i/description/text() }</bid_on_item> sort by (.) } </user> sort by (name) } </result>
Expected Result:
<result> <user> <name>Dee Linquent</name> <bid_on_item>Motorcycle</bid_on_item> <bid_on_item>Racing Bicycle</bid_on_item> </user> <user> <name>Jack Sprat</name> <bid_on_item>Old Bicycle</bid_on_item> <bid_on_item>Racing Bicycle</bid_on_item> </user> <user> <name>Mary Doe</name> <bid_on_item>Motorcycle</bid_on_item> <bid_on_item>Red Bicycle</bid_on_item> </user> <user> <name>Rip Van Winkle</name> </user> <user> <name>Roger Smith</name> <bid_on_item>Motorcycle</bid_on_item> <bid_on_item>Old Bicycle</bid_on_item> <bid_on_item>Racing Bicycle</bid_on_item> <bid_on_item>Red Bicycle</bid_on_item> </user> <user> <name>Tom Jones</name> <bid_on_item>Motorcycle</bid_on_item> <bid_on_item>Tricycle</bid_on_item> </user> </result>
The example document and queries in this Use Case were first created for a 1992 conference on Standard Generalized Markup Language (SGML). For our use, the Document Type Definition (DTD) and example document have been translated from SGML to XML.
This use case is based on an implicit (unnamed) input data set, using the DTD shown below.
<!NOTATION cgm PUBLIC "Computer Graphics Metafile"> <!NOTATION ccitt PUBLIC "CCITT group 4 raster"> <!ENTITY % text "(#PCDATA | emph)*"> <!ENTITY infoflow SYSTEM "infoflow.ccitt" NDATA ccitt> <!ENTITY tagexamp SYSTEM "tagexamp.cgm" NDATA cgm> <!ELEMENT report (title, chapter+)> <!ELEMENT title %text;> <!ELEMENT chapter (title, intro?, section*)> <!ATTLIST chapter shorttitle CDATA #IMPLIED> <!ELEMENT intro (para | graphic)+> <!ELEMENT section (title, intro?, topic*)> <!ATTLIST section shorttitle CDATA #IMPLIED sectid ID #IMPLIED> <!ELEMENT topic (title, (para | graphic)+)> <!ATTLIST topic shorttitle CDATA #IMPLIED topicid ID #IMPLIED> <!ELEMENT para (#PCDATA | emph | xref)*> <!ATTLIST para security (u | c | s | ts) "u"> <!ELEMENT emph %text;> <!ELEMENT graphic EMPTY> <!ATTLIST graphic graphname ENTITY #REQUIRED> <!ELEMENT xref EMPTY> <!ATTLIST xref xrefid IDREF #IMPLIED>
The queries in this use case are based on the following sample data. Line numbers have been added to the data to allow the results of queries to be conveniently specified.
0: <!DOCTYPE report SYSTEM "report.dtd"> 1: <report> 2: <title>Getting started with SGML</title> 3: <chapter> 4: <title>The business challenge</title> 5: <intro> 6: <para>With the ever-changing and growing global market, companies and 7: large organizations are searching for ways to become more viable and 8: competitive. Downsizing and other cost-cutting measures demand more 9: efficient use of corporate resources. One very important resource is 10: an organization's information.</para> 11: <para>As part of the move toward integrated information management, 12: whole industries are developing and implementing standards for 13: exchanging technical information. This report describes how one such 14: standard, the Standard Generalized Markup Language (SGML), works as 15: part of an overall information management strategy.</para> 16: <graphic graphname="infoflow"/></intro></chapter> 17: <chapter> 18: <title>Getting to know SGML</title> 19: <intro> 20: <para>While SGML is a fairly recent technology, the use of 21: <emph>markup</emph> in computer-generated documents has existed for a 22: while.</para></intro> 23: <section shorttitle="What is markup?"> 24: <title>What is markup, or everything you always wanted to know about 25: document preparation but were afraid to ask?</title> 26: <intro> 27: <para>Markup is everything in a document that is not content. The 28: traditional meaning of markup is the manual <emph>marking</emph> up 29: of typewritten text to give instructions for a typesetter or 30: compositor about how to fit the text on a page and what typefaces to 31: use. This kind of markup is known as <emph>procedural markup</emph>.</para></intro> 32: <topic topicid="top1"> 33: <title>Procedural markup</title> 34: <para>Most electronic publishing systems today use some form of 35: procedural markup. Procedural markup codes are good for one 36: presentation of the information.</para></topic> 37: <topic topicid="top2"> 38: <title>Generic markup</title> 39: <para>Generic markup (also known as descriptive markup) describes the 40: <emph>purpose</emph> of the text in a document. A basic concept of 41: generic markup is that the content of a document must be separate from 42: the style. Generic markup allows for multiple presentations of the 43: information.</para></topic> 44: <topic topicid="top3"> 45: <title>Drawbacks of procedural markup</title> 46: <para>Industries involved in technical documentation increasingly 47: prefer generic over procedural markup schemes. When a company changes 48: software or hardware systems, enormous data translation tasks arise, 49: often resulting in errors.</para></topic></section> 50: <section shorttitle="What is SGML?"> 51: <title>What <emph>is</emph> SGML in the grand scheme of the universe, anyway?</title> 52: <intro> 53: <para>SGML defines a strict markup scheme with a syntax for defining 54: document data elements and an overall framework for marking up 55: documents.</para> 56: <para>SGML can describe and create documents that are not dependent on 57: any hardware, software, formatter, or operating system. Since SGML documents 58: conform to an international standard, they are portable.</para></intro></section> 59: <section shorttitle="How does SGML work?"> 60: <title>How is SGML and would you recommend it to your grandmother?</title> 61: <intro> 62: <para>You can break a typical document into three layers: structure, 63: content, and style. SGML works by separating these three aspects and 64: deals mainly with the relationship between structure and content.</para></intro> 65: <topic topicid="top4"> 66: <title>Structure</title> 67: <para>At the heart of an SGML application is a file called the DTD, or 68: Document Type Definition. The DTD sets up the structure of a document, 69: much like a database schema describes the types of information it 70: handles.</para> 71: <para>A database schema also defines the relationships between the 72: various types of data. Similarly, a DTD specifies <emph>rules</emph> 73: to help ensure documents have a consistent, logical structure.</para></topic> 74: <topic topicid="top5"> 75: <title>Content</title> 76: <para>Content is the information itself. The method for identifying 77: the information and its meaning within this framework is called 78: <emph>tagging</emph>. Tagging must 79: conform to the rules established in the DTD (see <xref xrefid="top4"/>).</para> 80: <graphic graphname="tagexamp"/></topic> 81: <topic topicid="top6"> 82: <title>Style</title> 83: <para>SGML does not standardize style or other processing methods for 84: information stored in SGML.</para></topic></section></chapter> 85: <chapter> 86: <title>Resources</title> 87: <section> 88: <title>Conferences, tutorials, and training</title> 89: <intro> 90: <para>The Graphic Communications Association has been 91: instrumental in the development of SGML. GCA provides conferences, 92: tutorials, newsletters, and publication sales for both members and 93: non-members.</para> 94: <para security="c">Exiled members of the former Soviet Union's secret 95: police, the KGB, have infiltrated the upper ranks of the GCA and are 96: planning the Final Revolution as soon as DSSSL is completed.</para> 97: </intro> 98: </section> 99: </chapter> 100:</report>
Locate all paragraphs in the report (all "para" elements occurring anywhere within the "report" element).
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { input()//report//para } </result>
Expected Result:
Elements whose start-tags are on lines 6, 11, 20, 27, 34, 39, 46, 53, 56, 62, 67, 71, 76, 83, 90, 94
Locate all paragraph elements in an introduction (all "para" elements directly contained within an "intro" element).
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { input()//intro/para } </result>
Expected Result:
Elements whose start-tags are on lines 6, 11, 20, 27, 53, 56, 62, 90, 94
Locate all paragraphs in the introduction of a section that is in a chapter that has no introduction (all "para" elements directly contained within an "intro" element directly contained in a "section" element directly contained in a "chapter" element. The "chapter" element must not directly contain an "intro" element).
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { for $c in input()//chapter where empty($c/intro) return $c/section/intro/para } </result>
Expected Result:
Elements whose start-tags are on lines 90, 94
Locate the second paragraph in the third section in the second chapter (the second "para" element occurring in the third "section" element occurring in the second "chapter" element occurring in the "report").
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { (((input()//chapter)[2]//section)[3]//para)[2] } </result>
Expected Result:
Element whose start-tag is on line 67
Locate all classified paragraphs (all "para" elements whose "security" attribute has the value "c").
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { input()//para[@security = "c"] } </result>
Expected Result:
Element whose start-tag is on line 94
List the short titles of all sections (the values of the "shorttitle" attributes of all "section" elements, expressing each short title as the value of a new element.)
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { for $s in input()//section/@shorttitle return <stitle>{ $s }</stitle> } </result>
Expected Result:
Attribute values in start-tags on lines 23, 50, 59
Locate the initial letter of the initial paragraph of all introductions (the first character in the content [character content as well as element content] of the first "para" element contained in an "intro" element).
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { for $i in input()//intro/para[1] return <first_letter>{ substring(string($i), 1, 1) }</first_letter> } </result>
Expected Result:
Character after start-tag on lines 6, 20, 27, 53, 62, 90
Locate all sections with a title that has "is SGML" in it (all "section" elements that contain a "title" element that has the consecutive characters "is SGML" in its content). The string can be interrupted by sub-elements.
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { input()//section[contains(string(.//title), "is SGML")] } </result>
Expected Result:
Elements whose start-tags are on lines 50, 59
Same as (Q8a), but the string cannot be interrupted by sub-elements.
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { input()//section[contains(.//title/text(), "is SGML")] } </result>
Expected Result:
Element whose start-tag is on line 59
Locate all the topics referenced by a cross-reference anywhere in the report (all the "topic" elements whose "topicid" attribute value is the same as an "xrefid" attribute value of any "xref" element).
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { for $id in input()//xref/@xrefid return input()//topic[@topicid = $id] } </result>
Expected Result:
Element whose start-tag is on line 65
Locate the closest title preceding the cross-reference ("xref") element whose "xrefid" attribute is "top4" (the "title" element that would be touched last before this "xref" element when touching each element in document order).
Solution in XQuery:
<result> { let $x := input()//xref[@xrefid = "top4"], $t := input()//title[. << $x] return $t[last()] } </result>
Expected Result:
Given xref on line 79, element whose start-tag is on line 75
This use case is based on company profiles and a set of news documents which contain data for PR, mergers and acquisitions, etc. Given a company, the use case illustrates several different queries for searching text in news documents and different ways of providing query results by matching the information from the company profile and the content of the news items.
In this use case, the contains
function is used to test whether a string occurs
within a node or a string. Obviously, using
full-text functions would provide more powerful
searching, but the current Functions and Operators
draft does not have full-text functions.
This use case is based on an implicit (unnamed) input data set based on the following DTDs:
<!ELEMENT company (name, ticker_symbol?, description?, business_code, partners?, competitors?)> <!ELEMENT name (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT ticker_symbol (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT description (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT business_code (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT partners (partner+)> <!ELEMENT partner (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT competitors (competitor+)> <!ELEMENT competitor (#PCDATA)>
<!ELEMENT news (news_item*)> <!ELEMENT news_item (title, content, date, author?, news_agent)> <!ELEMENT title (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT content (par | figure)+ > <!ELEMENT date (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT author (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT news_agent (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT par (#PCDATA | quote | footnote)*> <!ELEMENT quote (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT footnote (#PCDATA)> <!ELEMENT figure (title, image)> <!ELEMENT image EMPTY> <!ATTLIST image source CDATA #REQUIRED >
The queries in this
use case are based on the following input data,
which is returned by the input()
function.
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="ISO-8859-1"?> <news> <news_item> <title> Gorilla Corporation acquires YouNameItWeIntegrateIt.com </title> <content> <par> Today, Gorilla Corporation announced that it will purchase YouNameItWeIntegrateIt.com. The shares of YouNameItWeIntegrateIt.com dropped $3.00 as a result of this announcement. </par> <par> As a result of this acquisition, the CEO of YouNameItWeIntegrateIt.com Bill Smarts resigned. He did not announce what he will do next. Sources close to YouNameItWeIntegrateIt.com hint that Bill Smarts might be taking a position in Foobar Corporation. </par> <par>YouNameItWeIntegrateIt.com is a leading systems integrator that enables <quote>brick and mortar</quote> companies to have a presence on the web. </par> </content> <date>1-20-2000</date> <author>Mark Davis</author> <news_agent>News Online</news_agent> </news_item> <news_item> <title>Foobar Corporation releases its new line of Foo products today</title> <content> <par> Foobar Corporation releases the 20.9 version of its Foo products. The new version of Foo products solve known performance problems which existed in 20.8 line and increases the speed of Foo based products tenfold. It also allows wireless clients to be connected to the Foobar servers. </par> <par> The President of Foobar Corporation announced that they were proud to release 20.9 version of Foo products and they will upgrade existing customers <footnote>where service agreements exist</footnote> promptly. TheAppCompany Inc. immediately announced that it will release the new version of its products to utilize the 20.9 architecture within the next three months. </par> <figure> <title>Presidents of Foobar Corporation and TheAppCompany Inc. Shake Hands</title> <image source="handshake.jpg"/> </figure> </content> <date>1-20-2000</date> <news_agent>Foobar Corporation</news_agent> </news_item> <news_item> <title>Foobar Corporation is suing Gorilla Corporation for patent infringement </title> <content> <par> In surprising developments today, Foobar Corporation announced that it is suing Gorilla Corporation for patent infringement. The patents that were mentioned as part of the lawsuit are considered to be the basis of Foobar Corporation's <quote>Wireless Foo</quote> line of products. </par> <par>The tension between Foobar and Gorilla Corporations has been increasing ever since the Gorilla Corporation acquired more than 40 engineers who have left Foobar Corporation, TheAppCompany Inc. and YouNameItWeIntegrateIt.com over the past 3 months. The engineers who have left the Foobar corporation and its partners were rumored to be working on the next generation of server products and applications which will directly compete with Foobar's Foo 20.9 servers. Most of the engineers have relocated to Hawaii where the Gorilla Corporation's server development is located. </par> </content> <date>1-20-2000</date> <news_agent>Reliable News Corporation</news_agent> </news_item> </news>
In addition, the following data, listing the partners and competitors of companies, is found in the file "company-data.xml".
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="ISO-8859-1"?> <!DOCTYPE company SYSTEM "company.dtd"> <company> <name>Foobar Corporation</name> <ticker_symbol>FOO</ticker_symbol> <description>Foobar Corporation is a maker of Foo(TM) and Foobar(TM) products and a leading software company with a 300 Billion dollar revenue in 1999. It is located in Alaska. </description> <business_code>Software</business_code> <partners> <partner>YouNameItWeIntegrateIt.com</partner> <partner>TheAppCompany Inc.</partner> </partners> <competitors> <competitor>Gorilla Corporation</competitor> </competitors> </company>
Find all news items where the string "Foobar Corporation" appears in the title.
Solution in XQuery:
input()//news_item/title[contains(./text(), "Foobar Corporation")]
Expected Results
<title>Foobar Corporation releases its new line of Foo products today</title> <title>Foobar Corporation is suing Gorilla Corporation for patent infringement </title>
Find news items where the Foobar Corporation and one or more of its partners are mentioned in the same paragraph and/or title. List each news item by its title and date.
Solution in XQuery:
define function partners(xs:string $company) returns element* { let $c := document("company-data.xml")//company[name = $company] return $c//partner } let $foobar_partners := partners("Foobar Corporation") for $item in input()//news_item where some $t in $item//title satisfies (contains($t/text(), "Foobar Corporation") and some $partner in $foobar_partners satisfies contains($t/text(), $partner/text())) or some $par in $item//par satisfies (contains(string($par), "Foobar Corporation") and some $partner in $foobar_partners satisfies contains(string($par), $partner/text())) return <news_item> { $item/title } { $item/date } </news_item>
Expected Result:
<news_item> <title> Gorilla Corporation acquires YouNameItWeIntegrateIt.com </title> <date>1-20-2000</date> </news_item> <news_item> <title>Foobar Corporation releases its new line of Foo products today</title> <date>1-20-2000</date> </news_item> <news_item> <title>Foobar Corporation is suing Gorilla Corporation for patent infringement </title> <date>1-20-2000</date> </news_item>
Find news items where a company and one of its partners is mentioned in the same news item and the news item is not authored by the company itself.
Solution in XQuery:
define function partners(xs:string $company) returns element* { let $c := document("company-data.xml")//company[name = $company] return $c//partner } for $item in input()//news_item, $c in document("company-data.xml")//company let $partners := partners($c/name) where contains(string($item), $c/name) and some $p in $partners satisfies contains(string($item), $p) and $item/news_agent != $c/name return $item
Expected Results: The expected results are the news item elements with the following titles:
Gorilla Corporation acquires YouNameItWeIntegrateIt.com
Foobar Corporation is suing Gorilla Corporation for patent infringement
For each news item that is relevant to the Gorilla Corporation, create an "item summary" element. The content of the item summary is the content of the title, date, and first paragraph of the news item, separated by periods. A news item is relevant if the name of the company is mentioned anywhere within the content of the news item.
Solution in XQuery:
for $item in input()//news_item where contains(string($item/content), "Gorilla Corporation") return <item_summary> { $item/title/text() }. { $item/date/text() }. { string(($item//par)[1]) } </item_summary>
Expected Result: (with whitespace reformatted for readability)
<item_summary> Gorilla Corporation acquires YouNameItWeIntegrateIt.com. 1-20-2000. Today, Gorilla Corporation announced that it will purchase YouNameItWeIntegrateIt.com. The shares of YouNameItWeIntegrateIt.com dropped $3.00 as a result of this announcement. </item_summary> <item_summary> Foobar Corporation is suing Gorilla Corporation for patent infringement. 1-20-2000. In surprising developments today, Foobar Corporation announced that it is suing Gorilla Corporation for patent infringement. The patents that were mentioned as part of the lawsuit are considered to be the basis of Foobar Corporation's <quote>Wireless Foo</quote> line of products. </item_summary>
This use case performs a variety of queries on namespace-qualified names.
This use case is based on a scenario in which a neutral mediator is acting with public auction servers on behalf of clients. The reason for a client to use this imaginary service may be anonymity, better insurance, or the possibility to cover more than one market at a time. The following aspects of namespaces are illustrated by this use case:
Syntactic disambiguation when combining XML data from different sources
Re-use of predefined modules, such as XLinks or XML Schema
Support for global classification schemas, such as the Dublin Core
The sample data consists of two records. The schema used for this data uses W3C XML Schema's schema composition to create a schema from predefined, namespace separated modules, and uses XLink to express references. Each record describes a running auction. It embeds data specific to an auctioneer (e.g. the company's credit rating system) and a taxonomy specific to a particular good (jazz records) in a framework that contains data common to all auctions (e.g. start and end time), using namespaces to distinguish the three vocabularies.
Note that namespace prefixes must be resolved to their Namespace URIs before matching namespace qualified names. It is not sufficient to use the literal prefixes to denote namespaces. Furthermore, there are several possible ways to represent namespace declarations. Therefore, processing must be done on the namespace processed XML Information Set, not on the XML text representation.
DTDs are not fully compatible with namespaces as they can not express the equality of nodes in the same namespace, but different namespace proxies. In a later version of this paper, an XML Schema should be added here.
This use case is based on an implicit (unnamed) input data set.
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="ISO-8859-1"?> <ma:AuctionWatchList xmlns:ma="http://www.example.com/AuctionWatch" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xmlns:anyzone="http://www.example.com/auctioneers#anyzone" xmlns:eachbay="http://www.example.com/auctioneers#eachbay" xmlns:yabadoo="http://www.example.com/auctioneers#yabadoo" > <!-- ________________________________________________________________________________ --> <ma:Auction anyzone:ID="0321K372910"> <ma:AuctionHomepage xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://www.example.com/item/0321K372910" /> <ma:Schedule> <ma:Open xmlns:dt="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" dt:type="timeInstant">2000-03-21:07:41:34-05:00</ma:Open> <ma:Close xmlns:dt="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" dt:type="timeInstant">2000-03-23:07:41:34-05:00</ma:Close> </ma:Schedule> <ma:Price> <ma:Start ma:currency="USD">3.00</ma:Start> <ma:Current ma:currency="USD">10.00</ma:Current> <ma:Number_of_Bids>5</ma:Number_of_Bids> </ma:Price> <ma:Trading_Partners> <ma:High_Bidder> <eachbay:ID>RecordsRUs</eachbay:ID> <eachbay:PositiveComments>231</eachbay:PositiveComments> <eachbay:NeutralComments>2</eachbay:NeutralComments> <eachbay:NegativeComments>5</eachbay:NegativeComments> <ma:MemberInfoPage xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://auction.eachbay.com/members?get=RecordsRUs" xlink:role="ma:MemberInfoPage" /> </ma:High_Bidder> <ma:Seller> <anyzone:ID>VintageRecordFreak</anyzone:ID> <anyzone:Member_Since>October 1999</anyzone:Member_Since> <anyzone:Rating>5</anyzone:Rating> <ma:MemberInfoPage xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://auction.anyzone.com/members/VintageRecordFreak" xlink:role="ma:MemberInfoPage" /> </ma:Seller> </ma:Trading_Partners> <ma:Details> <record xmlns="http://www.example.org/music/records"> <artist>Miles Davis</artist> <title>In a Silent Way</title> <recorded>1969</recorded> <label>Columbia Records</label> <remark> With Miles Davis (trumpet), Herbie Hancock (Electric Piano), Chick Corea (Electric Piano), Wayne Shorter (Tenor Sax), Josef Zawinul (Electric Piano & Organ), John McLaughlin (Guitar), and Tony Williams (Drums). The liner notes were written by Frank Glenn, and the record is in fine condition. </remark> </record> </ma:Details> </ma:Auction> <!-- ________________________________________________________________________________ --> <ma:Auction yabadoo:ID="13143816"> <ma:AuctionHomepage xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://auctions.yabadoo.com/auction/13143816" /> <ma:Schedule> <ma:Open xmlns:dt="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" dt:type="timeInstant">2000-03-19:17:03:00-04:00</ma:Open> <ma:Close xmlns:dt="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" dt:type="timeInstant">2000-03-29:17:03:00-04:00</ma:Close> </ma:Schedule> <ma:Price> <ma:Start ma:currency="USD">3.00</ma:Start> <ma:Current ma:currency="USD">3.00</ma:Current> <ma:Number_of_Bids>0</ma:Number_of_Bids> </ma:Price> <ma:Trading_Partners> <ma:High_Bidder> <eachbay:ID>VintageRecordFreak</eachbay:ID> <eachbay:PositiveComments>232</eachbay:PositiveComments> <eachbay:NeutralComments>0</eachbay:NeutralComments> <eachbay:NegativeComments>0</eachbay:NegativeComments> <ma:MemberInfoPage xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://auction.eachbay.com/showRating/user=VintageRecordFreak" xlink:role="ma:MemberInfoPage" /> </ma:High_Bidder> <ma:Seller xmlns:seller="http://www.example.com/auctioneers#eachbay"> <seller:ID>StarsOn45</seller:ID> <seller:PositiveComments>80</seller:PositiveComments> <seller:NeutralComments>1</seller:NeutralComments> <seller:NegativeComments>2</seller:NegativeComments> <ma:MemberInfoPage xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://auction.eachbay.com/showRating/user=StarsOn45" xlink:role="ma:MemberInfoPage" /> </ma:Seller> </ma:Trading_Partners> <ma:Details> <record xmlns="http://www.example.org/music/records"> <artist>Wynton Marsalis</artist> <title>Think of One ...</title> <recorded>1983</recorded> <label>Columbia Records</label> <remark xml:lang="en"> Columbia Records 12" 33-1/3 rpm LP, #FC-38641, Stereo. The record is still clean and shiny and looks unplayed (looks like NM condition). The cover has very light surface and edge wear. </remark> <remark xml:lang="de"> Columbia Records 12" 33-1/3 rpm LP, #FC-38641, Stereo. Die Platte ist noch immer sauber und glänzend und sieht ungespielt aus (NM Zustand). Das Cover hat leichte Abnutzungen an Oberfläche und Ecken. </remark> </record> </ma:Details> </ma:Auction> </ma:AuctionWatchList>
List all unique namespaces used in the sample data.
Solution in XQuery:
<Q1> { for $n in distinct-values( for $i in (input()//* | input()//@*) return namespace-uri($i) ) return <ns>{$n}</ns> } </Q1>
Expected Result:
<Q1> </ns>http://www.example.com/AuctionWatch</ns> </ns>http://www.example.com/auctioneers#anyzone</ns> </ns>http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink</ns> </ns>http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema</ns> </ns>http://www.example.com/auctioneers#eachbay</ns> </ns>http://www.example.org/music/records</ns> </ns>http://www.example.com/auctioneers#yabadoo</ns> </ns>xml</ns> </Q1>
Select the title of each record that is for sale.
Solution in XQuery:
declare namespace music = "http://www.example.org/music/records" <Q2> { input()//music:title } </Q2>
Expected Result:
<Q2 xmlns:music="http://www.example.org/music/records"> <music:title>In a Silent Way</music:title> <music:title>Think of One ...</music:title> </Q2>
Select all elements using datatypes from "XML Schema: Part 2" datatypes.
Solution in XQuery:
declare namespace dt = "http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" <Q3> { input()//*[@dt:*] } </Q3>
(Finds all nodes that have an attribute whose namespace matches the one specified.)
Expected Result:
<Q3 xmlns:dt="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"> <ma:Open xmlns:ma="http://www.example.com/AuctionWatch" dt:type="timeInstant">2000-03-21:07:41:34-05:00</ma:Open> <ma:Close xmlns:ma="http://www.example.com/AuctionWatch" dt:type="timeInstant">2000-03-23:07:41:34-05:00</ma:Close> <ma:Open xmlns:ma="http://www.example.com/AuctionWatch" dt:type="timeInstant">2000-03-19:17:03:00-04:00</ma:Open> <ma:Close xmlns:ma="http://www.example.com/AuctionWatch" dt:type="timeInstant">2000-03-29:17:03:00-04:00</ma:Close> </Q3>
List the target URI's of all XLinks in the document.
Solution in XQuery:
declare namespace xlink = "http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" <Q4> { for $hr in input()//@xlink:href return <ns>{ $hr }</ns> } </Q4>
(Binds $hr to attribute nodes named href. Concatenating the attribute node to a string extracts its value.)
Expected Result:
<Q4 xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"> <ns xlink:href="http://www.example.com/item/0321K372910"/> <ns xlink:href="http://auction.eachbay.com/members?get=RecordsRUs"/> <ns xlink:href="http://auction.anyzone.com/members/VintageRecordFreak"/> <ns xlink:href="http://auctions.yabadoo.com/auction/13143816"/> <ns xlink:href="http://auction.eachbay.com/showRating/user=VintageRecordFreak"/> <ns xlink:href="http://auction.eachbay.com/showRating/user=StarsOn45"/> </Q4>
Select all records that have a remark in German.
Solution in XQuery:
declare namespace music = "http://www.example.org/music/records" <Q5> { input()//music:record[music:remark/@xml:lang = "de"] } </Q5>
Expected Result:
<Q5 xmlns:music="http://www.example.org/music/records"> <music:record> <music:artist>Wynton Marsalis</music:artist> <music:title>Think of One ...</music:title> <music:recorded>1983</music:recorded> <music:label>Columbia Records</music:label> <music:remark xml:lang="en"> Columbia Records 12" 33-1/3 rpm LP, #FC-38641, Stereo. The record is still clean and shiny and looks unplayed (looks like NM condition). The cover has very light surface and edge wear. </music:remark> <music:remark xml:lang="de"> Columbia Records 12" 33-1/3 rpm LP, #FC-38641, Stereo. Die Platte ist noch immer sauber und glänzend und sieht ungespielt aus (NM Zustand). Das Cover hat leichte Abnutzungen an Oberfläche und Ecken. </music:remark> </music:record> </Q5>
Select the closing time elements of all AnyZone auctions currently monitored.
Solution in XQuery:
declare namespace ma = "http://www.example.com/AuctionWatch" declare namespace anyzone = "http://www.example.com/auctioneers#anyzone" <Q6> { input()//ma:Auction[@anyzone:ID]/ma:Schedule/ma:Close } </Q6>
Expected Result:
<Q6 xmlns:ma="http://www.example.com/AuctionWatch"> <ma:Close xmlns:dt="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" dt:type="timeInstant">2000-03-23:07:41:34-05:00</ma:Close> </Q6>
Select the homepage of all auctions where both seller and high bidder are registered at the same auctioneer.
Solution in XQuery:
declare namespace ma = "http://www.example.com/AuctionWatch" <Q7> { for $a in document("data/ns-data.xml")//ma:Auction let $seller_id := $a/ma:Trading_Partners/ma:Seller/*:ID, $buyer_id := $a/ma:Trading_Partners/ma:High_Bidder/*:ID where namespace-uri($seller_id) = namespace-uri($buyer_id) return $a/ma:AuctionHomepage } </Q7>
Expected Result:
<Q7 xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xmlns:ma="http://www.example.com/AuctionWatch" > <ma:AuctionHomepage xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://auctions.yabadoo.com/auction/13143816" /> </Q7>
Select all traders (either seller or high bidder) without negative comments
Solution in XQuery:
declare namespace ma = "http://www.example.com/AuctionWatch" <Q8> { for $s in input()//ma:Trading_Partners/(ma:Seller | ma:High_Bidder) where $s/*:NegativeComments = 0 return $s } </Q8>
Expected Result:
<Q8 xmlns:ma="http://www.example.com/AuctionWatch"> <ma:High_Bidder xmlns:eachbay="http://www.example.com/auctioneers#eachbay" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"> <eachbay:ID>VintageRecordFreak</eachbay:ID> <eachbay:PositiveComments>232</eachbay:PositiveComments> <eachbay:NeutralComments>0</eachbay:NeutralComments> <eachbay:NegativeComments>0</eachbay:NegativeComments> <ma:MemberInfoPage xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://auction.eachbay.com/showRating/user=VintageRecordFreak" xlink:role="ma:MemberInfoPage"/> </ma:High_Bidder> </Q8>
This use case illustrates how a recursive query might be used to construct a hierarchic document of arbitrary depth from flat structures stored in a database.
This use case is based on a "parts explosion" database that contains information about how parts are used in other parts.
The input to the use case is a "flat" document in which each different part is represented by a <part> element with partid and name attributes. Each part may or may not be part of a larger part; if so, the partid of the larger part is contained in a partof attribute. This input document might be derived from a relational database in which each part is represented by a row of a table with partid as primary key and partof as a foreign key referencing partid.
The challenge of this use case is to write a query that converts the "flat" representation of the parts explosion, based on foreign keys, into a hierarchic representation in which part containment is represented by the structure of the document.
The input data set uses the following DTD:
<!DOCTYPE partlist [ <!ELEMENT partlist (part*)> <!ELEMENT part EMPTY> <!ATTLIST part partid CDATA #REQUIRED partof CDATA #IMPLIED name CDATA #REQUIRED> ]>
Although the partid
and partof
attributes could
have been of type ID and IDREF, respectively, in this schema they are treated
as character data, possibly materialized in a straightforward way from a
relational database. Each partof
attribute matches exactly
one partid
. Parts having no partof
attribute are not
contained in any other part.
The output data conforms to the following DTD:
<!DOCTYPE parttree [ <!ELEMENT parttree (part*)> <!ELEMENT part (part*)> <!ATTLIST part partid CDATA #REQUIRED name CDATA #REQUIRED> ]>
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="ISO-8859-1"?> <partlist> <part partid="0" name="car"/> <part partid="1" partof="0" name="engine"/> <part partid="2" partof="0" name="door"/> <part partid="3" partof="1" name="piston"/> <part partid="4" partof="2" name="window"/> <part partid="5" partof="2" name="lock"/> <part partid="10" name="skateboard"/> <part partid="11" partof="10" name="board"/> <part partid="12" partof="10" name="wheel"/> <part partid="20" name="canoe"/> </partlist>
Convert the sample document from "partlist" format to "parttree" format (see DTD section for definitions). In the result document, part containment is represented by containment of one <part> element inside another. Each part that is not part of any other part should appear as a separate top-level element in the output document.
Solution in XQuery:
define function one_level (element $p) returns element { <part partid="{ $p/@partid }" name="{ $p/@name }" > { for $s in document("partlist.xml")//part where $s/@partof = $p/@partid return one_level($s) } </part> } <parttree> { for $p in document("partlist.xml")//part[empty(@partof)] return one_level($p) } </parttree>
Expected Result:
<parttree> <part partid="0" name="car"> <part partid="1" name="engine"> <part partid="3" name="piston"/> </part> <part partid="2" name="door"> <part partid="4" name="window"/> <part partid="5" name="lock"/> </part> </part> <part partid="10" name="skateboard"> <part partid="11" name="board"/> <part partid="12" name="wheel"/> </part> <part partid="20" name="canoe"/> </parttree>
Strongly typed and weakly typed data are both important kinds of XML data. Most of the queries in this document focus on wealy typed data that is governed by a DTD and does not contain XML Schema simple datatypes or named complex types. This use case explores XQuery's support for types, using data that is governed by a strongly typed XML Schema ???.
Note:
We intend to provide further use cases for our type system in future versions of this document. These use cases will illustrate other aspects of the type system, such as static type checking.
The schema for this example is the International Purchase Order schema taken from the XML Schema Primer, which imports a schema for addresses. Here is the main schema:
<schema targetNamespace="http://www.example.com/IPO" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" xmlns:ipo="http://www.example.com/IPO" elementFormDefault="qualified"> <annotation> <documentation xml:lang="en"> International Purchase order schema for Example.com Copyright 2000 Example.com. All rights reserved. </documentation> </annotation> <!-- include address constructs --> <include schemaLocation="address.xsd"/> <!-- include schemaLocation="address.xsd"/ --> <element name="purchaseOrder" type="ipo:PurchaseOrderType"/> <element name="comment" type="string"/> <element name="shipTo" type="ipo:Address"/> <element name="billTo" type="ipo:Address"/> <complexType name="PurchaseOrderType"> <sequence> <element name="shipTo" type="ipo:Address"/> <element name="billTo" type="ipo:Address"/> <element ref="ipo:comment" minOccurs="0"/> <element name="items" type="ipo:Items"/> </sequence> <attribute name="orderDate" type="date"/> </complexType> <complexType name="Items"> <sequence> <element name="item" minOccurs="0" maxOccurs="unbounded"> <complexType> <sequence> <element name="productName" type="string"/> <element name="quantity"> <simpleType> <restriction base="positiveInteger"> <maxExclusive value="100"/> </restriction> </simpleType> </element> <element name="USPrice" type="decimal"/> <element ref="ipo:comment" minOccurs="0"/> <element name="shipDate" type="date" minOccurs="0"/> </sequence> <attribute name="partNum" type="ipo:SKU" use="required"/> </complexType> </element> </sequence> </complexType> <simpleType name="SKU"> <restriction base="string"> <pattern value="\d{3}-[A-Z]{2}"/> </restriction> </simpleType> </schema>
Here is the schema for the address constructs:
<schema targetNamespace="http://www.example.com/IPO" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" xmlns:ipo="http://www.example.com/IPO" elementFormDefault="qualified"> <annotation> <documentation xml:lang="en"> Addresses for International Purchase order schema Copyright 2000 Example.com. All rights reserved. </documentation> </annotation> <complexType name="Address"> <sequence> <element name="name" type="string"/> <element name="street" type="string"/> <element name="city" type="string"/> </sequence> </complexType> <complexType name="USAddress"> <complexContent> <extension base="ipo:Address"> <sequence> <element name="state" type="ipo:USState"/> <element name="zip" type="positiveInteger"/> </sequence> </extension> </complexContent> </complexType> <complexType name="UKAddress"> <complexContent> <extension base="ipo:Address"> <sequence> <element name="postcode" type="ipo:UKPostcode"/> </sequence> <attribute name="exportCode" type="positiveInteger" fixed="1"/> </extension> </complexContent> </complexType> <!-- other Address derivations for more countries --> <simpleType name="USState"> <restriction base="string"> <enumeration value="AK"/> <enumeration value="AL"/> <enumeration value="AR"/> <!-- and so on ... --> <enumeration value="PA"/> </restriction> </simpleType> <!-- simple type definition for UKPostcode --> <simpleType name="UKPostcode"> <restriction base="string"> <pattern value="[A-Z]{1,2}[0-9R][0-9A-Z]? [0-9][A-Z]{2}"/> </restriction> </simpleType> </schema>
Here is the sample data used for the query:
<?xml version="1.0"?> <ipo:purchaseOrder xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns:ipo="http://www.example.com/IPO" orderDate="1999-12-01"> <shipTo exportCode="1" xsi:type="ipo:UKAddress"> <name>Helen Zoe</name> <street>47 Eden Street</street> <city>Cambridge</city> <postcode>CB1 1JR</postcode> </shipTo> <billTo xsi:type="ipo:USAddress"> <name>Robert Smith</name> <street>8 Oak Avenue</street> <city>Old Town</city> <state>PA</state> <zip>95819</zip> </billTo> <items> <item partNum="833-AA"> <productName>Lapis necklace</productName> <quantity>1</quantity> <USPrice>99.95</USPrice> <ipo:comment>Want this for the holidays!</ipo:comment> <shipDate>1999-12-05</shipDate> </item> </items> </ipo:purchaseOrder>
Count the invoices shipped to the United Kingdom.
Solution in XQuery:
import schema "ipo.xsd" declare namespace ipo="http://www.example.com/IPO" count( document("ipo.xml")//ipo:shipTo[. instance of element of type ipo:UKAddress] )
In this dataset, the data for an address does not contain the name of the country, and the name of the shipTo element is the same regardless of the country to which items are shipped. Only the types allow us to identify UK addresses - in the schema, there is one address type for UK addresses and another for US addresses, both derived from a common base class. In the above query, we use the UKAddress type to identify invoices shipped to the UK.
Write a function that tests an American address to check if it has the right zip code.
In our solution, we will assume zip code data is stored in a file called "zips.xml", which looks like this.
<zips> <row> <city>Old Town</city> <state>PA</state> <zip>95819</zip> </row> <row> <city>Durham</city> <state>NC</state> <zip>27701</zip> </row> <row> <city>Durham</city> <state>NC</state> <zip>27703</zip> </row> </zips>
Solution in XQuery:
import schema "ipo.xsd" import schema "zips.xsd" declare namespace ipo="http://www.example.com/IPO" declare namespace zips="http://www.example.com/zips" define function zip-ok(element of type ipo:USAddress $a) returns xs:boolean { some $i in document("zips.xml")/zips:zips/zips:row satisfies $i/zips:city = $a/ipo:city and $i/zips:state = $a/ipo:state and $i/zips:zip = $a/ipo:zip }
An attempt to call this functions with an element of the wrong address type raises an error. For instance, you can not call zip-ok() with an element of type UKAddress.
Note that the parameter for this function specifies the type rather than the element name, since it is written to be used with any element that has the proper address type - for instance, in our sample schema, 'billTo' and 'shipTo' are two different elements which may both have the USAddress type.
Write a function that tests a UK address to see if it has the right postal code.
For England, we store the information needed to test postal codes in a file called "postals.xml", which looks like this:
<postals> <row> <city>Cambridge</city> <prefix>CB</prefix> </row> <row> <city>Oxford</city> <prefix>OX</prefix> </row> </postals>
Solution in XQuery:
import schema "ipo.xsd" import schema "postals.xsd" declare namespace ipo="http://www.example.com/IPO" declare namespace pst="http://www.example.com/postals" define function postal-ok(element of type ipo:UKAddress $a) returns xs:boolean { some $i in document("postals.xml")/pst:postals/pst:row satisfies $i/pst:city = $a/ipo:city and xf:starts-with($a/ipo:postcode, $i/pst:prefix) }
Return purchase orders with an erroneous postal code or zip code (depending on whether it is a UK Address or a US Address).
Solution in XQuery:
import schema "ipo.xsd" import schema "postals.xsd" import schema "zips.xsd" declare namespace ipo="http://www.example.com/IPO" declare namespace pst="http://www.example.com/postals" declare namespace zips="http://www.example.com/zips" define function postal-ok(element of type ipo:UKAddress $a) returns xs:boolean { some $i in document("postals.xml")/pst:postals/pst:row satisfies $i/pst:city = $a/ipo:city and starts-with($a/ipo:postcode, $i/pst:prefix) } define function zip-ok(element of type ipo:USAddress $a) returns xs:boolean { some $i in document("zips.xml")/zips:zips/zips:row satisfies $i/zips:city = $a/ipo:city and $i/zips:state = $a/ipo:state and $i/zips:zip = $a/ipo:zip } define function address-ok( element of type ipo:Address $a ) returns xs:boolean { typeswitch ($a) case element of type ipo:USAddress $zip return zip-ok($zip) case element of type ipo:UKAddress $postal return postal-ok($postal) default return false() } for $p in document("ipo.xml")//ipo:purchaseOrder where not( address-ok($p/ipo:shipTo) and address-ok($p/ipo:billTo)) return $p
This query calls the functions defined in Q2 and Q3.
Note that the function address-ok() accepts any element whose type is ipo:Address, which is the base type for both ipo:UKAddress and ipo:USAddress. Note also that this function uses a typeswitch to select the appropriate function to test American or British addresses. This can be considered a primitive form of polymorphism.
Write a query that returns purchase orders where the name in the shipping address does not match the name in the billing address.
Solution in XQuery:
import schema "ipo.xsd" declare namespace ipo="http://www.example.com/IPO" define function names-match( element ipo:shipTo in ipo:purchaseOrder $s, element ipo:billTo in ipo:purchaseOrder $b ) returns xs:boolean { $s/ipo:name = $b/ipo:name } for $p in document("ipo.xml")//ipo:purchaseOrder where not( names-match( $p/ipo:shipTo, $p/ipo:billTo ) ) return $p
In this function, note that the function uses the element names rather than the type names to specify the parameters. The query should return an error if the function is called with two ipo:billTo elements by mistake, but it is not a mistake to have the shipping address and billing address have different types.
Note also that the schema says both of these elements are local elements, defined only within a purchase order. Since these elements are not globally defined, the parameters specify a schema context in which the name is defined. (In XML, local names prevent name clash, but they do not invoke any form of data hiding).
Find purchase orders where the billing address is not a USAddress, but at least one price is a USPrice.
Solution in XQuery:
import schema "ipo.xsd" declare namespace ipo="http://www.example.com/IPO" for $p in document("ipo.xml")//ipo:purchaseOrder, $s in $p/ipo:shipTo where not( $s instance of element of type ipo:USAddress) and exists( $p//ipo:USPrice ) return $p
In this schema, prices are derived directly from decimal, not from a common base type. That means that we have to use the element name USPrice to identify US prices. Addresses are part of a type hierarchy, and the element name, ipo:shipTo, does not tell us whether an address is a US price or not, so we have to test the type.
This example is rather contrived, since the schema specifies that all prices are USPrice elements. Nevertheless, it illustrates the ability to easily combine information derived from type information with information derived from structure.
Write a function that returns the text of a comment. Call this function for each shipping comment found in an item shipped to Helen Zoe on the date 1999-12-01.
The example in the XML Schema Primer uses the following example for substitution groups:
<element name="comment" type="string"/> . . . <element name="shipComment" type="string" substitutionGroup="ipo:comment"/> <element name="customerComment" type="string" substitutionGroup="ipo:comment"/>
The example in the XML Schema Primer provides the following sample data to illustrate these substitution groups:
<items> <item partNum="833-AA"> <productName>Lapis necklace</productName> <quantity>1</quantity> <USPrice>99.95</USPrice> <ipo:shipComment> Use gold wrap if possible </ipo:shipComment> <ipo:customerComment> Want this for the holidays! </ipo:customerComment> <shipDate>1999-12-05</shipDate> </item> </items>
Solution in XQuery:
import schema "ipo.xsd" declare namespace ipo="http://www.example.com/IPO" define function comment-text(element ipo:comment $c) returns xs:string { string( $c ) } for $p in document("ipo.xml")//ipo:purchaseOrder, $t in comment-text( $p//ipo:shipComment ) where $p/ipo:shipTo/ipo:name="Helen Zoe" and $p/ipo:orderDate = date("1999-12-01") return $t
In this query, the function specifies ipo:comment as the name of the element, but any element in the substitution group of ipo:comment may also be passed to this function. That means that we can call the same function for ipo:shipComment elements or ipo:customerComment elements - for instance, the following query also succeeds:
for $p in document("ipo.xml")//ipo:purchaseOrder where $p/ipo:shipTo/ipo:name="Helen Zoe" and $p/@orderDate = date("1999-12-01") return comment-text( $p//ipo:customerComment )
Find all comments found in an item shipped to Helen Zoe on the date 1999-12-01, including all elements in the substitution group for ipo:comment.
Solution in XQuery:
import schema "ipo.xsd" declare namespace ipo="http://www.example.com/IPO" for $p in document("ipo.xml")//ipo:purchaseOrder where $p/ipo:shipTo/ipo:name="Helen Zoe" and $p/@orderDate = date("1999-12-01") return ($p//ipo:customerComment | $p//ipo:shipComment | $p//ipo:comment )
This solution cheats. In the current Working Drafts, it is not possible to search for all elements in a substitution group without enumerating them. This is being discussed in the Working Groups.
Write a function that returns all comments found on an element, whether an item element or some other element that may have a comment.
Solution in XQuery:
import schema "ipo.xsd" declare namespace ipo="http://www.example.com/IPO" define function comments-for-element( element $e ) returns ipo:comment* { let $c := $e/(ipo:customerComment | ipo:shipComment | ipo:comment) return $c }
In this schema, comments can occur on either a purchase order or on an item. In a more complete schema, they could presumably occur in other areas as well. This function returns all comments found on an element, regardless of the name of the element, illustrating the need to write functions that can accept any element as a parameter.
Write a function that determines whether the person listed in a billTo element is known to be a deadbeat, using a US database.
This query assumes that "www.usa-deadbeats.com" maintains a database of deadbeats.
Solution in XQuery:
import schema "ipo.xsd" declare namespace ipo="http://www.example.com/IPO" define function deadbeat( element ipo:billTo of type ipo:USAddress $b ) returns xs:boolean { $b/ipo:name = document("www.usa-deadbeats.com/current")/deadbeats/row/name }
Note that this function specifies both the element name and the type. The element name is specified because we do not want to embarrass recipients of gifts by calling this function for the shipping address by mistake. The type is specifed because we would need to use a different database to identify deadbeats in other countries.
Write a function that computes the total price for a sequence of item elements.
Solution in XQuery:
import schema "ipo.xsd" declare namespace ipo="http://www.example.com/IPO" define function total-price( element ipo:item* $i ) returns xs:decimal { let $subtotals := for $s in $i return $s/ipo:quantity * $s/ipo:USPrice return sum( $subtotals ) }
Here is a query that calls the function we just defined to get the total for an invoice (before calculating taxes and shipping charges):
import schema "ipo.xsd" declare namespace ipo="http://www.example.com/IPO" for $p in document("ipo.xml")//ipo:purchaseOrder where $p/ipo:shipTo/ipo:name="Helen Zoe" and $p/ipo:orderDate = date("1999-12-01") return total-price($p//ipo:item)
This query illustrates the need to be able to pass a sequence as a parameter to a function.
The above query works under the assumption that no more than one purchase order is shipped to the same person on the same date. There is no unique identifier for the purchase orders in this schema; if there were, we would have used it to select the purchase order.
The editors thank the members of the XML Query Working Group, which produced the material in this document.
The use cases in this paper were contributed by the following individuals:
Use Case "R" | Don Chamberlin |
Use Case "XMP" | Mary Fernandez, Jerome Simeon, Phil Wadler |
Use Case "TREE" | Jonathan Robie |
Use Case "PARTS" | Michael Rys |
Use Case "NS" | Ingo Macherius |
Use Case "TEXT" | Umit Yalcinalp |
Use Case "SEQ" | Jonathan Robie |
Use Case "SGML" | Paula Angerstein |
Use Case "STRONG" | Jonathan Robie |
Use case "XMP" has been previously published in [Fernandez]. Use cases "Tree" and "Seq" have been previously published in [Robie99].
The editors also wish to thank the members of the other W3C Working Groups who have commented on earlier drafts, and Michael Dyck for his critical reading and helpful suggestions.
The following references are some of the works considered by the WG in deriving its use cases.